Call

Free advice line for Businesses

Call 0800 675 698

Unjustified Dismissal & Personal Grievance Defence for Employers

Expert Support When an Employee Challenges Their Dismissal

Speak to an expert or

@media (scripting: none){.dynamic-section-slot{display:none!important}}

Received a personal grievance from a former employee?

Been notified of mediation through MBIE?

Facing an Employment Relations Authority (ERA) claim for unjustified dismissal?

Employerline helps New Zealand employers respond to dismissal disputes, protect their business, and navigate the employment relations process with confidence.

When an employee alleges they were unfairly dismissed, the stakes can be high. Compensation claims, lost wages, legal costs, management time, and reputational damage can all arise from an unsuccessful defence. Obtaining expert guidance as early as possible can significantly improve your position and help avoid costly mistakes.

Speak with Employerline's employment relations specialists today.

@media (scripting: none){.dynamic-section-slot{display:none!important}}

Defending an Unjustified Dismissal Claim

In New Zealand, employees may raise a personal grievance if they believe a dismissal was not substantively justified or procedurally fair.

Even where an employer had legitimate concerns about misconduct, performance, or medical incapacity, a dismissal can still be challenged if the correct process was not followed.

Employerline works with employers to:

Assess the strength of their position
Review the dismissal process
Identify potential risks and weaknesses
Prepare responses to personal grievances
Assist with mediation preparation
Support employers through ERA proceedings
Help achieve practical and commercially sensible outcomes

The earlier you seek advice, the more options may be available.

@media (scripting: none){.dynamic-section-slot{display:none!important}}

Common Dismissal Claims We Help Employers Defend

Misconduct Dismissals

An employee may challenge a dismissal even when misconduct occurred.

We help employers demonstrate that:

Concerns were properly investigated
The employee was informed of the allegations
The employee was given an opportunity to respond
Relevant evidence was considered
The decision was reasonable in the circumstances.

@media (scripting: none){.dynamic-section-slot{display:none!important}}

Serious Misconduct Dismissals

Summary dismissal cases often attract significant scrutiny.

Employerline can assist employers in reviewing:

Investigation procedures
Suspension decisions
Evidence and witness statements
Disciplinary meeting outcomes
Procedural fairness requirements
Decision-making processes.

Our goal is to help employers establish that both the reason for dismissal and the process followed were appropriate.

Call our team today

Schedule a call

@media (scripting: none){.dynamic-section-slot{display:none!important}}

Poor Performance Dismissals

Performance-related terminations are among the most commonly challenged employment decisions.

We assist employers in demonstrating that they:

Identified performance concerns
Communicated expectations clearly
Provided support and training where appropriate
Allowed reasonable opportunities for improvement
Followed a fair performance management process.

Medical Incapacity Terminations

Dismissals arising from prolonged illness or incapacity can be particularly complex.

Employerline provides guidance on:

Medical evidence requirements
Consultation and procedural obligations
Alternative options considered
Reasonableness of the employer's decision
Documentation supporting the process.

Redundancy and Restructure Challenges

Employees may allege that a redundancy was not genuine or that consultation obligations were not met.

We help employers review and defend:

Business rationale for restructuring
Consultation processes
Employee communications
Selection decisions
Redundancy documentation.

@media (scripting: none){.dynamic-section-slot{display:none!important}}

Have You Received a Personal Grievance?

Receiving a personal grievance can feel overwhelming, particularly if you're unsure of your obligations or how to respond.

Employerline can help you:

Understand the allegations being made
Assess your legal position
Prepare a response strategy
Gather supporting documentation
Navigate settlement discussions
Prepare for mediation.

Many disputes can be resolved before progressing to formal proceedings when they are managed correctly from the outset.

@media (scripting: none){.dynamic-section-slot{display:none!important}}

Support Through MBIE Mediation

Mediation is often the first formal step in resolving an employment dispute. Proper preparation can significantly influence the outcome.

Employerline helps employers:

Understand the mediation process
Assess settlement options
Prepare supporting evidence
Develop negotiation strategies
Approach mediation with confidence.

Our advisors provide practical guidance both before and during the process.

Employment Relations Authority Support

If a matter progresses to the Employment Relations Authority, employers need a clear strategy and well-prepared documentation.

We assist employers with:

Reviewing the claim
Preparing responses
Organising evidence
Identifying key issues
Understanding procedural requirements
Managing risk throughout the process.

Being proactive can often improve outcomes and reduce unnecessary costs.

@media (scripting: none){.dynamic-section-slot{display:none!important}}

Why Employers Choose Employerline

Employer-Focused Advice

Everything we do is designed to support employers and protect business interests while ensuring compliance with employment relations obligations.

Experienced Employment Relations Specialists

Our team understands the practical realities of managing dismissals, grievances, disciplinary issues, and workplace disputes.

Nationwide Support

We work with employers across New Zealand in a wide range of industries and workplace environments.

Practical Commercial Solutions

We focus on achieving realistic outcomes rather than creating unnecessary complexity.

Help When You Need It

Employment disputes rarely happen at convenient times. Employerline is available to support employers when critical decisions need to be made.

Call now

Enquire now

@media (scripting: none){.dynamic-section-slot{display:none!important}}

Don't Wait Until the Claim Escalates

Many employers make the mistake of waiting until mediation has been scheduled or an ERA application has been filed before seeking advice.

The best time to obtain support is:

Immediately after receiving a personal grievance
When dismissal concerns are first raised
Before responding to an employee representative or lawyer
Prior to attending mediation
As soon as an ERA application is received.

Early intervention can significantly improve your ability to manage risk and defend your position.

@media (scripting: none){.dynamic-section-slot{display:none!important}}

How Employerline Can Help

Step 1: Tell Us What's Happened

Speak with one of our employment relations specialists and explain the circumstances surrounding the dismissal.

Step 2: Understand Your Position

We'll review the facts, identify risks, and outline your available options.

Step 3: Build a Defence Strategy

Receive practical support to help respond to the claim, prepare documentation, and manage the dispute effectively.

@media (scripting: none){.dynamic-section-slot{display:none!important}}

Protect Your Business with Expert Employment Relations Support

If a former employee has alleged they were unfairly dismissed, don't face the situation alone.

Whether you've received a personal grievance, are preparing for mediation, or need assistance responding to an Employment Relations Authority claim, Employerline can provide the practical guidance and support employers need.

Contact Employerline today for expert advice on defending unjustified dismissal and personal grievance claims.

Speak to an expert

Schedule a call